5 Br Private Vacation Home Vacation Rental In Tybee Island, Georgia

Nestled on beautiful Tybee Island, Wish Upon a Starfish Cottage is a lovingly updated 1940s gem that blends historic charm with modern comfort. This spacious beach retreat features five bedrooms and four full bathrooms, making it ideal for family vacations, group getaways, and reunions by the sea. Located on picturesque 2nd Avenue along Tybee’s beloved bike path, the home offers a relaxed island setting just a short stroll from the beach, shops, and local dining - offering the perfect home base for enjoying everything Tybee Island has to offer.

Why You'll Love Wish Upon a Starfish Cottage:

- Perfectly Situated for Beach Life: Located on picturesque 2nd Avenue, Tybee Island's beloved bike path, this charming cottage invites you to explore the island on two wheels. Bring your own bike or rent one nearby for a scenic ride. Just 2.5 blocks from beach access, you’re only a short stroll away from sandy shores and ocean breezes.

- A Blend of Old and New: Step inside to discover a stunning mix of classic Tybee Island charm paired with thoughtful modern updates. Bright beachy décor, soft color palettes, and cozy furnishings create a space that feels both stylish and inviting.

- Space for Everyone: The cottage offers two distinct living areas—perfect for multi-family groups or those seeking a little extra privacy. Whether you’re gathering for meals or relaxing after a day at the beach, there’s room for everyone to feel at home.

- Relaxing Indoor & Outdoor Spaces: Relax on the newly rebuilt second-story front porch, complete with a porch swing for morning coffee or evening chats. Inside, the open-plan living and dining area features comfortable seating, a 60-inch smart TV, and a dining table for six. The well-equipped kitchen includes all the essentials, from a full-size oven and dishwasher to entertaining-ready cookware.

The five bedrooms at Wish Upon a Starfish Cottage are thoughtfully arranged across two levels, providing both space and privacy. Upstairs, you’ll find three bedrooms: the primary bedroom with a king bed and smart TV, a second bedroom with a queen bed and smart TV, and a third bedroom featuring twin bunk beds. Downstairs, the ground level offers a private retreat with two additional bedrooms—one with a king bed and the other with two queen beds, both equipped with smart TVs. This level also includes a shared bathroom and a cozy living area with a sleeper sofa, perfect for extra guests or relaxation.

The backyard is fenced for your furry friends, it offers space to relax and enjoy the outdoors. Whether you're planning a family BBQ or simply unwinding after a day at the beach, the property ensures you’ll feel the island’s laid-back charm at every turn! Enjoy the newly rebuilt second-story front porch, complete with a porch swing, a favorite spot for morning coffee or evening wind-downs.

Sleeping Configuration:
Upper Unit:
Bedroom 1: King Bed
Bedroom 2: Two Queen Beds
Bedroom 3: Bunk Bed (1 Twin over 1 Full)
Living Room Upstairs: Sleeper Sofa
Lower Unit:
Bedroom 4: King Bed
Bedroom 5: Two Queen Beds
Living Room Downstairs: Sleeper Sofa

What is parking like for this home?
Guests will have dedicated, off-street parking for up-to 5 vehicles.

We can welcome your dog companions at this pet-friendly home, but we ask that you find other arrangements for cats, birds, and other furry friends. There is a $130 pet fee (non-refundable) with a 35 lb. maximum weight limit per dog and a limit of 2 dogs per reservation. Some homes may allow larger dogs; please inquire for more information.

*Wish Upon a Starfish Cottage is a spacious split-unit home offered as one exclusive property. When you book, your group enjoys full, private access to both units - ideal for multi-family vacations, friends traveling together, couples, or extended stays. While the units are not connected internally (guests step outside to move between them), this unique layout offers the perfect balance of togetherness and privacy, giving everyone room to relax while still sharing the same prime location.

Located near the beach, this vacation home is in South Beach, a neighborhood in Tybee Island. Harbour Town Lighthouse is a notable landmark, and the area's natural beauty can be seen at Tybee Island Beach and North Beach. Tybee Arts Center and Tybee Island Marine Science Center are also worth visiting. Surfing/body boarding, fishing, and swimming offer great chances to get out on the surrounding water, or you can seek out an adventure with ecotours nearby.