4 Br Private Vacation Home Vacation Rental In Mystic Island, New Jersey

Escape to Mystic Hideaway, your one-of-a-kind waterfront vacation home in Mystic Island, New Jersey, where Caribbean charm meets coastal comfort. Just minutes from the beautiful beaches of Long Beach Island (LBI) and a short drive to Atlantic City, this spacious retreat was designed for families and groups looking to relax, reconnect, and make unforgettable memories.

The home comfortably sleeps up to 12 guests, with the option to accommodate up to 15 guests by adding the private 5th bedroom suite complete with its own en-suite bathroom.

Resort-Style Outdoor Living

The backyard is truly the centerpiece of Mystic Hideaway.

Cool off in the large private in-ground pool, enjoy dinner at the outdoor table with seating for 12, or unwind in one of several waterfront lounging areas while taking in peaceful lagoon views.

As the sun begins to set, gather around the fire pit, relax in the oversized outdoor rocking chairs, or head down to the floating dock where a waterfront bench offers the perfect place to enjoy your morning coffee, evening cocktail, or a quiet cigar while watching boats drift by.

Elevated above the deck is the home’s signature feature—our modern Caribbean-inspired Sky Bar. Complete with string lights, adjustable ambient lighting, intimate seating, and sleek glass railings for unobstructed water views, it’s the perfect place for happy hour, celebrations, or simply enjoying warm summer evenings under the stars.

Outdoor fun continues with oversized lawn games, multiple seating areas, and plenty of space for everyone to spread out and relax.

Seamless Indoor & Outdoor Living

Large sliding glass doors bring the outdoors inside.

The open-concept kitchen and dining area features two oversized sliding glass doors overlooking the pool and lagoon, allowing you to keep an eye on the kids swimming while preparing meals or gathering around the dining table.

The Surf Room features an impressive 8-foot sliding glass door with beautiful water views and direct access to the Sky Bar.

The Aloha Room also opens directly outdoors through its own sliding patio door leading to the rooftop entertainment area.

Natural light fills the home, creating a bright, welcoming atmosphere throughout.

Four Unique Themed Bedrooms

Every bedroom has its own personality, making Mystic Hideaway feel more like a boutique resort than a typical vacation rental.

Surf Room
Wake up to waterfront views through an oversized 8-foot sliding glass door that opens directly onto the Sky Bar.

Aloha Room
A relaxing tropical-inspired retreat with direct access to the outdoor entertainment deck.

Pirate Room
One of our guest favorites, this immersive pirate-themed bedroom sleeps three guests and is full of authentic details. A handcrafted ship’s mast glows with realistic flickering candle-style lanterns, creating the feeling of sleeping aboard an old sailing ship. It’s a magical space that kids love and adults appreciate for its craftsmanship and creativity.

Sand Dune Room
Inspired by the quiet beauty of the Jersey Shore, this peaceful beach-themed bedroom sleeps two and features calming coastal décor reminiscent of windswept dunes and seaside mornings.

Spacious Gathering Areas

Whether you’re entertaining or simply relaxing after a day at the beach, there’s room for everyone.

The spacious main living room features comfortable seating centered around a cozy fireplace—perfect for movie nights, board games, or relaxing together after sunset.

A second lounge area adjacent to the dining room provides another comfortable space to read, chat, or watch TV while remaining connected to the rest of the home.

A striking mounted sailfish serves as a conversation piece and adds to the home’s nautical character.

The long hallway connecting the bedrooms features a beautiful beach mural that continues the coastal theme throughout the home.

Fully Equipped for Extended Stays

The fully stocked kitchen includes everything needed to prepare anything from quick breakfasts to large family dinners.

Additional conveniences include:

• Full-size washer and dryer
• High-speed Wi-Fi
• Smart TVs
• Central air conditioning and heat
• Parking for up to 4 vehicles on the property

A Warm Welcome from the Moment You Arrive

Your vacation begins before you even step inside.

A charming boardwalk-style entrance, complete with landscape lighting, guides you to the front door, setting the tone for the relaxed coastal experience waiting inside.

Close to Everything

Mystic Hideaway is perfectly located for exploring the best of the Jersey Shore.

You’ll be just minutes from:

Long Beach Island (LBI) beaches
Local marinas and boat launches
Fishing, kayaking, paddleboarding, and boating
Waterfront restaurants and seafood markets
Golf courses
Water parks
Atlantic City casinos, entertainment, and nightlife
Shopping and family attractions

Why Guests Love Mystic Hideaway

✔ Sleeps up to 12 guests (15 with optional private suite)
✔ Large private in-ground pool
✔ Waterfront location with beautiful sunset views
✔ Caribbean-inspired Sky Bar
✔ Outdoor dining for 12
✔ Fire pit
✔ Floating dock with waterfront seating
✔ Oversized rocking chairs
✔ Large outdoor games
✔ Glass railings for unobstructed lagoon views
✔ Four uniquely themed bedrooms
✔ Spacious open-concept living
✔ Two indoor lounge areas
✔ Fully stocked kitchen
✔ Washer and dryer
✔ Parking for four vehicles
✔ Minutes to LBI beaches (8 Beach passes included)
✔ Minutes to Atlantic City

Whether you’re enjoying coffee by the water, spending the afternoon in the pool, gathering around the fire pit, or ending the evening under the glow of the Sky Bar lights, Mystic Hideaway offers the perfect blend of relaxation, comfort, and unforgettable waterfront memories.

Located in Mystic Island, a neighborhood in Tuckerton, this vacation home is in a rural area and on the waterfront. Tuckerton Seaport & Baymen's Museum and Historic Tuckerton Seaport are cultural highlights, and some of the area's attractions include Mystic Islands Park and Eagleswood Amusement Park. Looking to enjoy an event or a game while in town? See what's happening at Skydive East Coast or Beach Haven Tennis Center.