5 Br Private Vacation Home Vacation Rental In Geneva, New York

Summary:

Relax, explore, and reconnect at Cast Away—a spacious lake house right on Seneca Lake. Perfect for wine trail adventures, summer lake days, and cozy fall or winter getaways, this home delivers in every season. With lake views, a fire pit, kayaks, a game room, and multiple entertainment spaces, you’ll have everything you need for a memorable Finger Lakes escape.
The Space:

Welcome to Cast Away—a spacious lakefront retreat designed for comfort, connection, and unforgettable Finger Lakes memories. Whether you're planning a summer kayaking trip, a wine trail weekend, or a cozy fall getaway, this home has you covered.
🛏 Bedrooms

🛌 King Bedroom – Oversized with lake views, Smart TV, blackout shades, ample storage, and a private ensuite bath

🛌 Queen Bedroom 1 – Lake views, blackout shades, and convenient charging stations

🛌 Queen Bedroom 2 – Located at the front of the house with classic charm and blackout shades

🛌 Queen Bedroom 3 – Also located at the front of the house with blackout shades and plenty of space

🛏 Twin Trundle Bedroom – A private room downstairs with two twin beds, perfect for kids or extra guests
🛁 Bathrooms

🚿 Ensuite Bathroom – Located in the king bedroom with walk-in shower

🛁 Shared Full Bath – Upstairs hallway bath with a walk-in shower

🚽 Main Floor Half Bath – Convenient for shared use during the day
🛋 Living & Lounging Spaces

📺 Main Living Room – Features a Smart TV, fireplace, and comfortable seating for relaxing after lake days

🎲 Board Games Provided – Ideal for unplugged fun and cozy evenings indoors
🍽 Kitchen & Dining

🍳 Spacious Kitchen – Fully stocked with modern appliances, ample counter space, and additional dining area

🍷 Formal Dining Room – Seats 10 comfortably, great for group meals or game night
🎮 Game Room (Shared)

🕹 Located in the detached garage (open 10:30 AM – 9:00 PM)

Features ping pong, air hockey, foosball, PAC-MAN, and a Smart TV

Shared with The Cottage at Cast Away
🌅 Outdoor Space

🍽 Upper Deck – Two dining tables, a cozy outdoor seating area, and a gas grill (propane provided)

🔥 Lower Lawn – Fire pit with Adirondack chairs, 5 kayaks, and direct dock access

Note: Outdoor spaces are private to this home except for the shared dock, which is the only outdoor shared amenity with the cottage
🌟 Why Stay Here

🌧️ Perfect Rain or Shine – Game room, fireplace, board games & Smart TVs

🌊 Lakefront Fun – Long dock for swimming, relaxing, or launching kayaks

🛶 Kayaks Included – Paddle from your private shoreline

🕹 Entertainment for All Ages – From PAC-MAN to fire pits

🛏 Designed for Comfort – Blackout shades, Smart TVs, and room for everyone
📍 Prime Location

🍷 On the Seneca Lake Wine Trail, steps from wineries and tastings

🍽 3 minutes to Ports Café & Roy’s Marina

🛍️ 8 minutes to Downtown Geneva for shopping, dining, and exploring

🥾 Within 30 minutes of the region’s best hiking trails and waterfalls
Whether you're planning lakeside relaxation, wine-fueled adventures, or cozy nights in, Cast Away is the ideal home base for your next Finger Lakes stay.
Guest Access:

Guests have full access to the main house, deck, fire pit, and dock. The dock and detached game room are shared only with the Cottage at Cast Away (unless booked together for larger groups).
The Neighborhood:

Located on White’s Point, this home offers quiet lakefront charm just minutes from Geneva. You're close to wineries, restaurants, and Hobart William Smith Colleges—perfect for exploring the region.
Getting Around:

A car is highly recommended for exploring the area. Private taxis/car services and private wine tours are available.
Other Things to Note:

➡️This property can be rented in conjunction with the cottage on the property (Cottage at Cast Away) to sleep up to 10 people in total, and then have the dock and game room only for your guests.

➡️ A Pack ’n Play is available BY REQUEST ONLY and provided free of charge. Please let us know in advance if you’d like one so we can have it ready for your arrival.

➡️ Shared Spaces – Dock & game room are shared unless both homes are booked

➡️ Please note: We provide cooking basics, with the exception of oil at this time—it will be included in the future.

➡️ Quiet hours are from 10 PM to 7 AM per town ordinance. This is a peaceful area with year-round residents—please be respectful during your stay.

➡️ Parking – Only 4 cars are allowed to park at the property. 3 cars in the driveway, 1 additional on the grass across the road

➡️ Boats may not be docked at the property.

➡️ Fire pit, kayaks, & game room – Use at your own risk

➡️ Train Crossing: A nearby train occasionally passes (~1–2 times per day). It's brief and typically quiet, but always stop and look both ways when crossing the tracks.

➡️ Guests must sign Get RED-y Vacations’ guest rental agreement prior to check-in.

➡️ A security camera is located at the entrance of the property for safety and monitoring of arrivals.

➡️ Some amenities may be seasonal and availability can vary depending on weather and time of year.
Interaction with Guests:

We offer 24/7 guest support — we're always just a message or call away if you need anything during your stay. While we’re here to help at any time, we also respect your privacy and won’t interrupt your visit unless absolutely necessary.

Located in Geneva, this vacation home is on the waterfront. The area's natural beauty can be seen at Seneca Lake and Keuka Lake, while Geneva History Museum and Smith Center for the Arts are cultural highlights. Traveling with kids? Consider Seneca Lake Sprayground and Muranda Cheese Company. Take an opportunity to explore the area for water adventures such as fishing.