Company Logo

Rare Property In Center Montclair

Residential Real Estate for Sale

Updated on Sep 18, 2026

View more like this | Visit MONTCLAIR, NJ | Contact Mayor 22
Image for Rare Property In Center Montclair with ID of: 91099


Rare Property in Center Montclair

Two Family House, Art Studios, Parking for Fifteen Vehicles

Short Walk to Church St. Center & Walnut St. NYC Train Station - Across from Paper Plane!

One of the Best Neighborhoods in Montclair


Includes huge finished workshops for art studios, music, yoga, home offices, cottage industry, hobby use, and/or
third apartment - Accessory Dwelling Unit (ADU)


69 North Fullerton Ave.
Montclair, NJ
07042



Charming 1870s Victorian farmhouse - Keep as two-family or convert back to single family, as originally designed.

Or, keep as a two-family but double its size. Since it is zoned for two-family use, this could be done without a variance.

The lot may be large enough to accommodate doubling of the size of the two-family without special approval. The two units would be reconfigured as a much larger duplex.

Having checked with the zoning office, and if my understanding is correct, the footprint of the original house should be able to be significantly increased, with just a building permit and site plan review. As long as the new house is attached to the original house, and they are each just one unit, it would still be conforming as a two-family house. The current setbacks would need to be maintained, and an equivalent amount of blacktop in the rear would need to be removed to conform to the permeability code (some other considerations apply, include runoff.)

It could be rented out, or, the duplex can be converted to two condominiums and sold separately. No variance is needed for this either.

And/or... add a 3rd unit, an Accessory Dwelling Unit (ADU) - a newly permitted use. This also requires no variance!

So many possibilities!


The house was restored in the 1990s and is situated on an over-sized lot of 0.3037 acres. (source: Essex County tax report) (13,622 square feet)

The style of the house is simple and rustic, however it was completely restored over the past several years, including custom storm windows, blown-in insulation, oil-finished fir floors, original clapboard, recent electric and plumbing infrastructure, boiler, oil tank, and roof.

The main advantage is the parking / work space behind the house. The location is adjacent to a number of large apartment buildings that have little or no parking for their tenants.

This property would be a very attractive opportunity for a contractor who needs space to store vehicles, scaffolding and other equipment, and/or an entrepreneur who needs work/live space for woodworking, graphic arts, web design, music studio, etc.

Included are two accessory buildings of finished studio space measuring about 1,400 square feet. Both have separate electric service, recent drywall and are fully insulated. The larger building features five skylights, a Vermont Castings wood stove, track lighting and ceilings which measure twelve feet in height at the peak.

Usage of studios is ancillary to house. They are perfect for art studios, home offices, woodworking or hobby, and may be built on to for additional space. There is plenty of room for expansion!

Great space for: visual arts, music, dance, design, fashion, photography, video, architecture, computer office, contracting, workshop, shared space for startups, renting guest rooms, bed and breakfast, BNB, Airbnb, etc.

Although not designated as an historic property, it is the owner's hope that the restored exterior visible from the street will be preserved.


- Legal two-family
- Can be sold as one property, or two separate condominiums
- Two detached workshop buildings in rear, fully insulated, separate utilities
- One workshop building in rear can be converted to a 3rd unit as an Accessory Dwelling Unit (ADU)
- Over-sized building lot, room for expansion to house and studios
- Huge parking area for 15 vehicles
- Great central location, walking distance to Bloomfield Ave, Church Street and Montclair center
- Walking distance to Walnut Street Train Station
- Property is on a hill - does not flood!


Upstairs apt consists of:
- Entrance hall on ground floor
- Stairwell
- Landing
- Eat-in Kitchen
- Bath
- Two rooms on second floor (or three rooms - a partition that was removed can be replaced to make three rooms)
- One room + office/study on third floor

Bottom apt consists of:
- Eat-in Kitchen
- Bath
- Three rooms
(Note: one room can be given over to upstairs apt)

Owner is a New Jersey licensed real estate agent.


Represented by
CEIL ADKINS
CENTURY 21 Gemini LLC
201.888.7763


Survey illustrating oversized lot with house and two art studios:
Image for Rare Property In Center Montclair with ID of: 1728





Image for Rare Property In Center Montclair with ID of: 1732
Image for Rare Property In Center Montclair with ID of: 1730
Image for Rare Property In Center Montclair with ID of: 1734
Image for Rare Property In Center Montclair with ID of: 1720
Interior, Studio
ESSEX COUNTY FULL TAX REPORT
2022-2023


TOWNSHIP: MONTCLAIR
PROPERTY MAILING ADDRESS: 69 N FULLERTON AVE, MONTCLAIR, NJ 07042

OWNER NAME: KNAPP, ANDREW W.
OWNER'S ADDRESS: 69 N FULLERTON AVE, MONTCLAIR, NJ 07042

BUILDING DESCRIPTION: 2SF11GF 2 FAM
BLOCK/BLOCK SUFFIX: 3202/0000
LOT/LOT SUFFIX: 00002/0000
ACRES: .3037
LOTSIZE: 54 X 245
YEAR BUILT: 1887
TAX PARCEL ID: 1613-03202-0000-00002-0000-

TAX INFORMATION
TAX YEAR: 2022 - 23
TOTAL TAX: $12,589.76 (approx)
TAX ZONE: R2
DEED BOOK: 5188
TAX SPECIAL ZONE:
DEED PAGE: 11

PROPERTY CLASS: 2
LAND ASSESSMENT: $196,100
TAX RATE: 2.301
IMPROVEMENT ASSESSMENT: $186,800
TOTAL TAXABLE ASSESSMENT: $382,900
TAX RATIO: 102.52
CALCULATED TAX AMOUNT: $12,589.76 (approx)



MONTCLAIR FULL TAX REPORT

Block/Lot/Qual: 3202. 2.
Tax Account Id: 6263
Property Location: 69 NO. FULLERTON AVENUE, MONTCLAIR, NJ 07042
Property Class: 2 - Residential
Land Value: 196,100
Improvement Value: 186,800
Total Assessed Value: 382,900

Tax Rate per $100 of Valuation
COUNTY TAX 0.540
COUNTY OPEN SPACE TAX 0.018
DISTRICT SCHOOL TAX 1.761
LOCAL SCHOOL TAX 0.115
LOCAL MUNICIPAL TAX 0.814
MUNICIPAL LIBRARY TAX 0.040
SPECIAL IMPRV DIST 0.233



Information is gleaned from various sources and is deemed RELIABLE but not GUARANTEED.

All room sizes, lot measurements and tax information are approximate and must be verified independently.
Comps:

https://www.redfin.com/NJ/Montclair/Undisclosed-address-07042/home/36225078

https://www.redfin.com/NJ/Montclair/86-Park-St-07042/home/36221124

https://www.redfin.com/NJ/Montclair/129-Chestnut-St-07042/home/36221169

https://www.redfin.com/NJ/Montclair/113-Harrison-Ave-07042/home/36220104

https://www.redfin.com/NJ/Montclair/188-Park-St-07042/home/36222059

https://www.redfin.com/NJ/Montclair/49-Union-St-07042/home/36224077

https://www.redfin.com/NJ/Montclair/26-Washington-St-07042/home/36224866

https://www.redfin.com/NJ/Montclair/33-N-Willow-St-07042/home/36224922

https://www.redfin.com/NJ/Montclair/35-N-Willow-St-07042/home/36224923
Image for Rare Property In Center Montclair with ID of: 91090
Image for Rare Property In Center Montclair with ID of: 91091
1st Floor Study
Image for Rare Property In Center Montclair with ID of: 91093
Living Room, 1st Floor
Image for Rare Property In Center Montclair with ID of: 91095
Bedroom, 1st Floor
Image for Rare Property In Center Montclair with ID of: 91097
1st Floor Kitchen
Seller purchased the property in 1991 and acted as GC in its restoration, overseeing several subcontractors in:

- architectural planning
- removal of composite siding
- clapboard siding restoration
- installation of new wooden storm windows
- re-roofing
- removal of underground oil tank
- installation of new above-ground oil tank
- installation of new boiler
- new electrical service to 5 panels, extensive rewiring
- 220 service in basement
- new plumbing infrastructure
- kept antique fixtures
- new concrete bathroom floors using period-styled tiles
- enclosing of rear porch, shored-up structure, insulation, sheetrock, wall of windows, new rear exit stairs with pressure-treated structure
- copper re-lining of Yankee gutters
- new kitchen installations with custom cabinets
- scraping and oiling original wood floors
- removal, cleaning, painting and reattachment of original steam radiators
- blown-in insulation in walls and floors
- batt insulation, sheetrock in attic and art studios
- skylights
- wood burning stove & chimney in studio
- working fireplace mantel reconstruction
- reconfiguration of room layout to facilitate changing back to single-family
- reinforcing studio roof & ceiling


NOTE: Photos are not current

As of 2023, one of the rear workshop buildings can be converted to an Unattached Accessory Dwelling (UAD) to create a 3rd living unit. See links below for specs and more information:
Map

Rare Property in Central Montclair

69 North Fullerton Avenue Montclair, NJ 07042

goodideazs, LLC is not affiliated with the authors of this post nor is it responsible for its content, the accuracy and authenticity of which should be independently verified.