Company Logo

139 Bayview Isle Drive Residential Single Family Detached $4,495,000 — Listed by Brett Newman, Coldwell Banker Schmitt Islamorada

Updated on Jul 21, 2024

Timeless Waterfront Charm in Venetian Shores Islamorada - Indulge in classic charm with... $4,495,000

Address 139 Bayview Isle Drive
Plantation Key, FL 33036
Living Area2,304 square feet
Listing Agent
(305) 393-1770
85996 Overseas Highway
(305) 664-4470
Timeless Waterfront Charm in Venetian Shores, Islamorada - Indulge in classic charm with this meticulously positioned waterfront residence in sought-after Venetian Shores. A dream come true for those who appreciate spectacular sunsets and unparalleled boating opportunities in the Florida Keys. Step into the gracious embrace of a bygone era in this residence poised directly on Snake Creek, the gateway to the Atlantic Ocean and Florida Bay, with prime fishing, diving, and waterfront dining just minutes away by boat. A celebration of classic waterfront living, the home's first floor unfolds with a spacious split plan, showcasing a large living room with a dining area, a family/game room blessed with water views on three sides, a water-view kitchen, and a central sunset-view screen porch. Three bedrooms, including two master suites--one featuring a private waterfront porch--and three full baths (two en suite), harmoniously combine casual refinement and comfort. Ascend a spiral staircase to the crown jewel--a top floor with panoramic water views, private balconies, and limitless possibilities. This space transforms into a fourth bedroom suite, a guest efficiency, or the grandkids' playhouse, complete with a kitchenette, dining area, seating space, beds/bunk space, a full bath, and two closets. Moor your boat in the protected cut-in boat slip with davits. Delight in the waterside deck and Tiki hut, ideal for fishing or grilling, all while enjoying passing boats, dolphins, and sea life. Additional amenities include an outdoor shower, two carports, a storage/tackle room, covered seating and an elevator lift to the main floor. Recent upgrades include new storm shutters throughout and new impact windows to fortify the stairway tower. These enhancements add to the aesthetic appeal and are also crucial for windstorm insurance. This waterfront haven isn't just a residence - it's a lifestyle. Seize this once-in-a-generation opportunity to make this dream lifestyle your own.


  • Year: 2023
  • $20,034
  • Appliances

  • Dryer
  • Oven
  • Range
  • Refrigerator
  • Washer
  • Floor coverings

  • Carpet
  • Tile
  • Rooms

  • Bedroom: 4
  • Full bath: 4
  • General

  • Property type: Residential
  • Property sub type: Single Family Detached
  • Living area: 2304
  • Lot size: 0.17
  • Year built: 1983
  • Listing title: Residential - Single Family - Plantation Key, FL
  • Full bathrooms: 4
  • Architecture style: Other
  • Building unit count: 1
  • Has elevator: yes
  • Exterior types: Concrete
  • Legal description: LT 19 VENETIAN SHORES PLAT NO 5 PLANTATION KEY PB6-68 (see deed)
  • Is new construction: no
  • Num floors: 3.0
  • Roof types: Metal
  • View types: Water
  • Is waterfront: yes
  • Listing Details

  • Mls name: Florida Keys Board of REALTORS ®
  • MLS Identifier: FLKEYSMLSFL
  • MLS Number: 607971
  • Provider name: Coldwell Banker Schmitt Islamorada
  • Provider Category: Broker
  • Property Type: Residential
  • Property sub type: Single Family Detached
  • Listing Category: Purchase
  • Office Key: FLKEYSMLSFL-20060624040347191526000000
  • Office ID: 20060624040347191526000000
Copyright © 2024 Florida Keys Board of REALTORS ®. All rights reserved. All information provided by the listing agent/broker is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed and should be independently verified.


More Properties In ISLAMORADA, FL

Photo for MM #72 MM #72 Lots And Land $4,995,000
Islamorada, FL

Once in a lifetime opportunity to own approximately 15,500 sq.ft. +/- of land on Craig Key, the most spectacular private Bayfront island in the FL Keys. Just south of Islamorada, this offering...

Photo for 75261 Overseas Highway Residential Single Family Detached $5,900,000
Islamorada, FL

Welcome home to the Balboa Beach House! This classic and simple beauty sits perched on the edge of the Atlantic on the southern side of Islamorada, Lower Matecumbe. Enter this custom built 2020...

Photo for 101 Gulfview Drive Residential Condominium $1,450,000
Islamorada, FL

This stunning top floor end unit in Bay Harbour with ocean and harbor views from every room also includes a 50' boat slip with 25,000# Boat Lift! BAY HARBOUR ALLOWS 7-DAY RENTALS with a Village of...

Photo for 81216 Old Highway Residential Single Family Detached $1,400,000
Islamorada, FL

Beautiful Downtown Islamorada Cottage! This newly constructed home is located on an oversized lot with a pool, outdoor entertaining area, plenty of storage, parking, and handicap access. The home...

Photo for 190 Venetian Drive Residential Single Family Detached $2,550,000
Islamorada, FL

LOCATION! LOCATION! LOCATION! This property is at the end of Venetian Drive with an open water view of Florida Bay, a great place to build your perfect piece of paradise. With 120' feet of seawall...

Photo for 133 Orange Lane Lots And Land $415,000
Islamorada, FL

Fabulous Plantation Beach lot only 3 lots from the bayfront Homeowner's Park! This lot is currently #39 in BPAS system. Plantation Beach is a lovely neighborhood with bayfront and non waterfront...

Photo for 80450 Overseas Highway Residential Condominium $999,000
Islamorada, FL

BRING ALL OFFERS! Motivated Seller offering owner financing on this one of a kind property in central Islamorada! Rare opportunity to own this detached Condominium/Home which sits apart and on its...

Photo for 141 Aregood Lane Residential Single Family Detached $1,625,000
Islamorada, FL

Ocean View Completely Remodeled Townhouse in Beautiful Islamorada!This beautifully updated town home offers 2 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms and a powder room including an ocean view Master Suite, with...

Photo for 144 Anglers Way Residential Single Family Detached $2,200,000
Islamorada, FL

Anglers Reef home and Boat Dock for sale, Islamorada's Upscale Oceanfront Gated Community. Direct Oceanfront home with deeded dock #3. This home features 2 huge bedrooms, 3 bathrooms, a carport & 3...

Photo for 88181 Old HWY Highway Residential Condominium $925,000
Islamorada, FL

Calling all Anglers, This condominium comes with a 30 ft. boat slip #54 and can accommodate up to 32 ft. easily. The ground-level unit is situated on the corner of the beach. Enjoy views of the...


How will climate change affect your home?
139 Bayview Isle Drive
Plantation Key, FL 33036
Get your free full report.

goodideazs, LLC is not affiliated with the authors of this post nor is it responsible for its content, the accuracy and authenticity of which should be independently verified.